Why pension scheme trustees find ESOG and ORA challenging – and practical ways to get started

By Laura Casserly, Assurance Director at Assure UK

In recent months, I’ve sat down with many trustees who’ve shared their worries with me, sometimes over a Teams call, sometimes across a meeting table.

Nearly all recognise that Effective System of Governance (ESOG) and Own Risk Assessment (ORA) matter. But I hear, time and again, how daunting the prospect can feel on top of everything else trustees are expected to manage.

It’s a very human reaction. Even the most experienced boards can feel swamped by the scale of regulation, unclear on where to begin, or nervous about what a review might uncover.

I want to share what I’ve learnt, both from trustees who’ve tackled these challenges and from my own work supporting boards through this process. With a few practical steps, it really is possible to turn regulatory anxiety into clarity and confidence.

Mountain Welcome Image

The complexity and time burden challenge

Trustees are under significant pressure. Whether it’s managing end-game strategies for defined benefit (DB) schemes, responding to operational shifts within defined contribution (DC) schemes or keeping pace with broader regulatory changes, there’s a lot on trustees’ plates.

Adding another governance project can feel overwhelming. The General Code itself is detailed and trustees often express frustration with the complexity and sheer volume of guidance available. They rightly ask:

  • What exactly do we need to do?
  • How do we know we’re compliant?
  • What’s the real value in this beyond ticking regulatory boxes?

The fear of what might be uncovered

Another common concern trustees share is the apprehension about what a thorough ESOG review might reveal. Many trustees feel their relationships with employers, administrators, lawyers, investment consultants and auditors are strong and productive.

Naturally, they worry that examining these processes closely might expose uncomfortable issues or require significant operational changes.

But, from experience, avoiding these concerns never resolves them – it only delays addressing them proactively.

Practical steps to reduce anxiety and get started

Thankfully, trustees don’t have to navigate this alone. Here’s my advice, drawn from working with multiple trustee boards on their governance journeys:

1. Utilise checklists and frameworks

Simplify your starting point by leveraging checklists and structured frameworks already available. At Assure UK, we’ve analysed the regulations extensively, condensing them into clear, manageable actions. Using structured checklists helps trustees:

  • Clearly identify required documentation.
  • Evaluate gaps in monitoring controls.
  • Pinpoint areas needing policy updates.

2. Engage with your advisors early

Don’t underestimate the insights your professional advisors can offer. Your lawyers, auditors, administrators and consultants have likely supported numerous trustees through similar exercises and can provide valuable guidance. Specifically, they can:

  • Offer practical templates and guidance documents.
  • Share anonymised case studies to help you avoid common pitfalls.
  • Provide a sense check on your initial assessments.

3. Learn from your peers

Trustees who have completed ESOG and ORA exercises can be an invaluable resource. Engage actively with industry bodies that facilitate peer learning. Hearing about the experiences of other trustee boards can:

  • Provide reassurance about common challenges.
  • Highlight practical, effective solutions.
  • Encourage your board to take proactive next steps confidently.

Trustees often feel reassured when they see concrete examples of how others have successfully navigated their ESOG and ORA processes. Engaging with industry forums, attending trustee networking events or joining webinars organised by pension scheme bodies can significantly reduce anxiety.

Learning directly from your peers’ practical experiences and seeing tangible outcomes can demystify the process, making the whole exercise feel far more achievable.

The benefits far outweigh the initial concerns

Trustees who’ve embraced ESOG and ORA reviews consistently report tangible benefits:

  • Greater clarity about scheme operations.
  • Stronger oversight and more effective risk management.
  • Improved confidence in their governance role.

Getting started can indeed seem daunting but remember, proportionality and practicality are central to the General Code. It’s about adding real value to your governance, not creating unnecessary work.

Ready to take the next step?

To help trustees take practical action immediately, we’ve developed a detailed yet simple ESOG & ORA readiness checklist. This tool will guide you through critical first steps:

  • Collating necessary governance documents.
  • Identifying and filling gaps in your current processes.
  • Confirming compliance deadlines clearly.

👉 Get in touch for a personalised conversation about your specific governance needs. Good governance isn’t just about compliance. It’s about confidence and clarity. Let’s navigate this process together.