Why Pension Scheme Trustees Switch Pension Audit Firms
Five Reasons to Switch Pension Audit Firm
Switch Pension Audit Firm?
As a pension scheme trustee or manager with extensive experience, you understand an auditor’s critical role in your scheme’s financial health and compliance.
We’ve analysed the primary reasons trustees decide to switch pension audit firms and found five key factors.
Three of these are commercial actions that could be avoided if the auditing firm performs well. One stems from the auditor’s decisions, and the last is rooted in good governance practices.
This means that 60% of the reasons trustees switch auditors are preventable.
Let’s delve into these reasons to provide valuable insights and benchmarks for your decision-making process when considering switching pension audit firms.

1. Poor Service Delivery
Poor service from a pension scheme audit firm can significantly hinder trustees’ ability to fulfil their duties effectively. This issue often manifests in several ways:
a. Ineffective Communication
Clear and consistent communication is the cornerstone of an auditor-trustee relationship.
Trustees rely on auditors for timely updates, detailed explanations of the audit process, findings, and emerging concerns. When communication is sparse, delayed, or unclear, trustees lack the essential insights to make informed decisions.
Additionally, suppose the audit firm doesn’t fully grasp your scheme’s unique requirements. This can lead to incomplete or inaccurate audit results, eroding confidence in the audit process and prompting trustees to switch pension audit firms.
b. Subpar Audit Quality and Thoroughness
An auditor’s expertise in pension schemes is crucial. If the audit team lacks the necessary experience, they may fail to identify risks, control weaknesses, or compliance issues vital to your scheme’s integrity.
Such oversights fall short of regulatory standards and leave trustees with an incomplete picture of the scheme’s financial health, potentially putting assets and members at risk.
This can be a significant reason to switch pension audit firms.
c. Lack of Responsiveness and Value-Added Insights
Trustees expect auditors to respond to their inquiries and provide proactive recommendations to enhance the scheme’s financial health.
An auditor who is slow to respond or fails to offer valuable insights hinders the trustees’ ability to manage the scheme effectively.
Furthermore, inconsistent fees, undisclosed costs, or unexpected charges indicate a lack of transparency and respect for the trustees’ budget. This contributes to poor service perception and motivates a switch of pension audit firms.
2. High Costs and Inconsistent Fees
Audit fees that are too high or increase annually without clear justification can strain a pension scheme’s resources.
We’ve observed fee increases of up to 20% year over year, which is significant even considering recent inflation rates.
When these costs are not justified by improved service or audit quality, trustees start exploring options to switch pension audit firms.
Significant Savings Are Possible
Even when trustees are satisfied with the service quality of their current auditor, they may explore other options to ensure they receive fair pricing.
In many cases, they find that by switching pension audit firms, they can achieve substantial savings—sometimes up to 50% in our experience—without compromising on service quality.
3. Lack of Proactivity
A proactive auditor is invaluable to a pension scheme.
Proactivity involves anticipating potential issues, staying ahead of regulatory changes, and providing strategic insights. When an audit firm is not proactive, trustees may find themselves unprepared for compliance updates or unaware of emerging risks.
This reactive approach forces trustees into a constant state of catching up rather than enabling them to plan strategically for the scheme’s future.
This lack of proactivity is a compelling reason to switch pension audit firms.
4. Auditor’s Decision to Exit the Market
Sometimes, the decision to switch pension audit firms is prompted by the audit firm’s commercial choices, such as exiting the pension scheme market.
While this is beyond the trustees’ control, finding a new auditor who can seamlessly take over and maintain the scheme’s compliance and financial integrity is necessary.
5. Good Governance and the Need for Fresh Perspectives
Adhering to good governance practices often involves rotating auditors to gain new insights and perspectives.
Over time, an auditor may become too familiar with a scheme, potentially leading to complacency. Introducing a new auditor can reduce this risk by bringing fresh ideas, methodologies, and an objective viewpoint.
Thus, trustees may switch pension audit firms as part of good governance.
The Value of Regular Auditor Rotation
Rotating auditors every three to five years strikes a balance between maintaining continuity and benefiting from new insights.
A new pension scheme audit firm can offer best practices based on its experience with other schemes, helping trustees align more closely with current regulatory expectations and industry trends.
This change also signals to stakeholders—scheme members, regulators, and sponsors—that the trustees are committed to transparency and proactive governance. Therefore, regularly considering a switch of pension audit firms is an important aspect of good governance.
Making the Transition Seamless with Assure UK
Switching pension audit firms doesn’t have to be daunting. At Assure UK, we’ve been perfecting a hassle-free transition process since 2003.
One of our first clients said, “I’ll change auditor provided it is hassle-free,” and we’ve made it our mission to deliver exactly that.
Whether you’re planning a well-timed change or need to switch pension audit firms for other reasons, we’re here to make the process smooth and efficient.
Our pension scheme audit specialists team is ready to provide the high-quality service, proactive insights, and value your scheme deserves.
If you’re considering a switch, don’t hesitate to reach out.
Send us a direct message or contact one of our team members, and we’ll guide you through every step of the process.
Assure UK’s Approach to Pension Scheme Audits
Assure UK was founded in late 2012 as a dedicated and specialist pension schemes audit firm that offers pension trustees and managers a level of customer service they didn’t think was possible.
A Specialist Pension Scheme Auditor You Can Rely On
Regardless of the size of your pension scheme, you need everything to work like clockwork so that sign-off can be achieved within seven months of your scheme’s year-end.
Assure UK does that with a hassle-free, timely, and expert service that takes the pressure off you. Oh, and with the added benefit of fixed fees from the outset, you’ll have additional peace of mind.
As a focused specialist firm in pension scheme audits, our team of experts brings a depth of experience and knowledge to pension audits that few general accountancy firms can match. Make your audit with us smooth and tailored to your needs, and know that we have met, advised on, and dealt with all manner of risk areas.
An endorsement of our expertise in pension scheme audits is that we are one of only four accountancy firms in the UK that are on the Pension Protection Fund’s Audit Services Panel.
For more information about our services or advice on improving your pension audits and assurance reporting, please connect with us on social media, sign up for our newsletter, and regularly visit our website.
Alternatively, call us at 020 7112 8300, email info@assureuk.co.uk, or book a meeting.
Related information and articles
When is a Good Time for a Pension Audit Review?
Pension Scheme Auditor Checklist Part One: Qualifications and Accreditations
Pension Scheme Auditor Checklist Part Two: Experience
Pension Scheme Auditor Checklist Part Three: Regulatory Understanding
Pension Scheme Auditor Checklist Part Four: Reputation
Pension Scheme Auditor Checklist Part Five: Independence
Cyber Security: a Checklist of What Pension Scheme Trustees Should Know
Basics of the Pension Scheme ORA