Effective System of Governance FAQs

ESOG: Frequently Asked Questions

ESOG FAQ: The introduction of the General Code of Practice by The Pensions Regulator has emphasised governance standards for occupational pension schemes. A key requirement is that schemes must have an Effective System of Governance (ESOG).

These FAQ’s tackle the commonly asked questions from professional trustees and scheme managers seeking to understand, implement and maintain their ESOG in line with regulatory expectations.

ESOG FAQ: Olivia, a manager at Assure UK, talks with colleagues about common questions asked about ESOG

1. What is an ESOG?

An ESOG (Effective System of Governance) is a comprehensive framework that covers how a pension scheme is governed, including policies, structures, processes and controls that enable it to be appropriately managed, securely and in members’ best interests.

2. Who needs to have an ESOG?

Most occupational pension schemes must have an ESOG. The only exceptions are certain small or executive-only arrangements. Even smaller schemes still need appropriate internal controls and proportionate governance arrangements.

3. Is having internal controls the same as having an ESOG?

No. Internal controls are one part of an ESOG. The ESOG also includes governance structure, policies, investment oversight, risk management and communications.

4. Where does the requirement for an ESOG come from?

It stems from UK regulations implementing the IORP II Directive, and is formalised in the General Code of Practice issued by The Pensions Regulator (TPR) in March 2024.

5. What should an ESOG include?

An ESOG should cover:

  • Governance structure (e.g., trustee roles, committees)
  • Documented policies (e.g., remuneration, adviser appointments)
  • Risk management framework and internal controls
  • Investment governance
  • Member communication and administration

6. How detailed should an ESOG be?

The ESOG should be proportionate to the scheme’s size, nature, and complexity. Larger or more complex schemes will need more developed frameworks. The key is that it is effective and evidence-based.

7. Is there a standard template for an ESOG?

No, but many schemes prepare an “ESOG manual” to collate their policies and governance documentation. While TPR does not mandate a format, the ESOG must be comprehensive and well-documented.

The ORA is a formal, documented review of how effectively the ESOG operates in practice. It assesses governance and risk exposures and identifies any needed improvements. It is a requirement for schemes with 100 or more members.

9. When is the first ORA due?

Within 12 months of the scheme’s first year-end after 28 March 2024. For example, if your year-end is 31 December 2024, your ORA is due by 31 December 2025.

10. How often must the ORA be repeated?

At least every three years, or sooner if there is a material change in the scheme’s governance or risk profile.

11. Do we need to submit the ORA to TPR?

Not currently. However, trustees must have a documented ORA available in case of regulatory engagement. TPR expects it to be a substantial and evidenced process.

12. What happens if we don’t have an ESOG?

Failure to establish an ESOG could be viewed as a breach of the scheme’s legal duties under section 249A of the Pensions Act 2004. TPR may take enforcement action or consider the scheme’s governance as inadequate.

13. How do we know if our ESOG is good enough?

Trustees should assess their ESOG against the expectations in the General Code and industry best practice. Regular reviews, peer comparisons, and independent governance assessments can all help.

14. Does the ESOG need to be approved by the trustee board?

Yes. The trustee board is responsible for governance and must have oversight of all components of the ESOG. Key documents should be formally reviewed and approved.

15. What policies are required as part of the ESOG?

The General Code highlights the need for several core policies, including:

  • Remuneration policy
  • Appointment of advisers policy
  • Continuity/succession planning
  • Risk management and internal control policy
  • Communication and disclosure policy

16. How often should we review our ESOG?

Each component of the ESOG should be reviewed at least once every three years. More frequent reviews are encouraged, particularly in areas like risk management or data governance.

17. Can an adviser or third party help develop an ESOG?

Yes. Many schemes engage governance specialists (like Assure UK) to perform gap analyses, draft ESOG documents, or provide assurance reviews. This can ensure the ESOG is effective, proportionate, and fit for purpose.

18. What role does proportionality play?

TPR expects trustees to apply proportionality when designing their ESOG. The framework should match the scheme’s scale and complexity, but all key components should be present and documented.

19. What are common pitfalls in developing an ESOG?

  • Treating the ESOG as a box-ticking exercise
  • Failing to document existing processes
  • Not reviewing policies regularly
  • Overlooking the need for trustee training
  • Not assigning ownership for ESOG maintenance

20. How can Assure UK support our ESOG journey?

In addition to this ESOG FAQ, we provide practical, proportionate help to:

  • Assess your existing governance
  • Identify gaps and prioritise actions
  • Draft and implement policies
  • Facilitate or independently review your ORA
  • Ensure ongoing compliance with the General Code

We offer ESOG support to help you through the process. Contact us to arrange a consultation and get started with strengthening your scheme’s governance.


ESOG FAQ, further reading: